I must say that the thing that most disappoints me about this process is the fact that, after extending offers to the “chosen ones,” Admissions sent out a few rejections and then has let the rest of us “dangle.” As an attorney here in the United States who has been a trial lawyer for over fifteen years, and a member of three Bars, including California (which, with New York and Florida are the three hardest bars to pass in the US) my dignity has been offended. And, yes, Phi Beta Kappa at Yale. I wanted to take the BCL in order to make a transition to being a barrister in the UK. I rather feel that I’ve earned my stripes and it bugs me that I am being “dissed.” Not a way to treat people, imo.
Long time lurker here when it comes to the BCL, but in no way an authority on the subject (not a student, nor an applicant). My understanding is that the BCL is an academic degree, and so less emphasis is placed on work experiences. There are however other degrees at Oxford (MSc in Taxation/Masters in Law and Finance) and Cambridge (Masters in Corporate Law), which are more geared towards those from industry. I know that the MSc in Taxation near exclusively features professionals amongst its cohorts, but not completely of course - as shown by Miki. It may just be that from an academic perspective, your stripes - while significant and impressive - aren't the 'right' stripes?
I think one of the more annoying aspects of the whole ordeal is what you mentioned at the end, Oxford and Cambridge, and the near monopoly they have over the Bar in England and Wales means their degrees gate-keep access to a profession, degrees which the universities aim/claim to be academic in nature but are informally and intrinsically tied to industry.
Just how it is I'm afraid, nevertheless, best of luck with being called to the Bar!
[Edited by Shahenshah on Mar 19, 2023]
[quote]I must say that the thing that most disappoints me about this process is the fact that, after extending offers to the “chosen ones,” Admissions sent out a few rejections and then has let the rest of us “dangle.” As an attorney here in the United States who has been a trial lawyer for over fifteen years, and a member of three Bars, including California (which, with New York and Florida are the three hardest bars to pass in the US) my dignity has been offended. And, yes, Phi Beta Kappa at Yale. I wanted to take the BCL in order to make a transition to being a barrister in the UK. I rather feel that I’ve earned my stripes and it bugs me that I am being “dissed.” Not a way to treat people, imo. [/quote]<br><br>Long time lurker here when it comes to the BCL, but in no way an authority on the subject (not a student, nor an applicant). My understanding is that the BCL is an academic degree, and so less emphasis is placed on work experiences. There are however other degrees at Oxford (MSc in Taxation/Masters in Law and Finance) and Cambridge (Masters in Corporate Law), which are more geared towards those from industry. I know that the MSc in Taxation near exclusively features professionals amongst its cohorts, but not completely of course - as shown by Miki. It may just be that from an academic perspective, your stripes - while significant and impressive - aren't the 'right' stripes? <br><br>I think one of the more annoying aspects of the whole ordeal is what you mentioned at the end, Oxford and Cambridge, and the near monopoly they have over the Bar in England and Wales means their degrees gate-keep access to a profession, degrees which the universities aim/claim to be academic in nature but are informally and intrinsically tied to industry. <br><br>Just how it is I'm afraid, nevertheless, best of luck with being called to the Bar!