What Chances do You think I have?


gar33

I am 22 and will graduate this year as the best student ever of a top portuguese law school, but probably unknown in the U.S... I applied to Yale, Harvard, Chicago and NYU. I really prefer Yale, as I want to pursue teaching and research. My GPA is 3.8, my TOEFL score is 293 and I have some professional experience (among other things, I did some part-time consultancy work for OECD on "PPP and multilateral surveillance among African developing countries"). I hope to be admitted but I'm affraid being so young might be a problem... and I stressed quite clearly in all the applications that my interests are of the scholarly type. In fact, my personal statements are more like research agendas... What chances do you think I have, especially concerning Yale?

I am 22 and will graduate this year as the best student ever of a top portuguese law school, but probably unknown in the U.S... I applied to Yale, Harvard, Chicago and NYU. I really prefer Yale, as I want to pursue teaching and research. My GPA is 3.8, my TOEFL score is 293 and I have some professional experience (among other things, I did some part-time consultancy work for OECD on "PPP and multilateral surveillance among African developing countries"). I hope to be admitted but I'm affraid being so young might be a problem... and I stressed quite clearly in all the applications that my interests are of the scholarly type. In fact, my personal statements are more like research agendas... What chances do you think I have, especially concerning Yale?
quote
Michaeeel

The best student ever of a top law school ?? Whoaoaoa !!

"He who speaks without modesty will find it difficult to make his words good." Confucius

More seriously, we're not the Yale Admission Board. Many criteria are taken into account (grades, letters of recommendation, professional experience, extra-curricular activities, etc.).

The best student ever of a top law school ?? Whoaoaoa !!

"He who speaks without modesty will find it difficult to make his words good." Confucius

More seriously, we're not the Yale Admission Board. Many criteria are taken into account (grades, letters of recommendation, professional experience, extra-curricular activities, etc.).
quote
gar33

Fair reply... but did you notice I said it is a top PORTUGUESE law school probably UNKNOWN in the US? First of all, it is a top law school in Portugal; secondly, it is not Harvard. And yes... I am the best student ever... it is really not a question of modesty or not, it is a matter of GPA (hey, I never said I'm the most intelligent fellow or something of the sort...). In fact, I don't believe that people can be fully evaluated from the standpoint of their academic records, but the fact remains: what other objective measure? I tried to do my best in the statements and so because I expect to be competing with other "best students ever", probably comming from highly appreciated institutions. Portugal is a small country!

Anyway, I am quite aware that nobody here is from de Office :-) I just wanted to hear a serious opinion from you guys...

Regards!

Fair reply... but did you notice I said it is a top PORTUGUESE law school probably UNKNOWN in the US? First of all, it is a top law school in Portugal; secondly, it is not Harvard. And yes... I am the best student ever... it is really not a question of modesty or not, it is a matter of GPA (hey, I never said I'm the most intelligent fellow or something of the sort...). In fact, I don't believe that people can be fully evaluated from the standpoint of their academic records, but the fact remains: what other objective measure? I tried to do my best in the statements and so because I expect to be competing with other "best students ever", probably comming from highly appreciated institutions. Portugal is a small country!

Anyway, I am quite aware that nobody here is from de Office :-) I just wanted to hear a serious opinion from you guys...

Regards!
quote
tt

Hi gar33:

First, congrats over your excellent GPA and toefl score.You must be an oustanding student in Portugal.To be honest, if I were you(it's too late now!) I would await some time before applying to US Top Law schools in order to gain some work experience after graduating.Remenber, it's about masters, not a JD program. If you would add some real work experience I positive your odds would be very, very high.Anyways,maybe I'm wrong(applications are age blind)and you will be accepted in a top law school where you did apply(if it's the case, please, let me know because I have friend in the pretty same situation).Again, congrats and good luck!

Hi gar33:

First, congrats over your excellent GPA and toefl score.You must be an oustanding student in Portugal.To be honest, if I were you(it's too late now!) I would await some time before applying to US Top Law schools in order to gain some work experience after graduating.Remenber, it's about masters, not a JD program. If you would add some real work experience I positive your odds would be very, very high.Anyways,maybe I'm wrong(applications are age blind)and you will be accepted in a top law school where you did apply(if it's the case, please, let me know because I have friend in the pretty same situation).Again, congrats and good luck!
quote
vakil

Relax. Of all factors age probably matters the least. I was the youngest in my class at 22. But there are several people who are in the 23-25 range.

Relax. Of all factors age probably matters the least. I was the youngest in my class at 22. But there are several people who are in the 23-25 range.
quote
Roberto27

Congratulations on your accomplishments! You are a brilliant student with lots of success to come along. Would you mind telling me your secret for attaining so high a Toefl Score? I mean, you almost got 300!!! That's very impressive.!!!

Congratulations on your accomplishments! You are a brilliant student with lots of success to come along. Would you mind telling me your secret for attaining so high a Toefl Score? I mean, you almost got 300!!! That's very impressive.!!!
quote
Paul

I think you have very very good chances. I am glad I am not a portuguese applicant from your law school. Yale will be the toughest one. You are competing not only with the best from Portugal but also the best from Europe. Did you get a letter from your law school / professor stating that you are the best GPA ever? That might help...

On the Toefl score, my understanding is that the Toefl is not a criterion to rank candidates. They just want to eliminate the applicants who will not understand the classes. That is all. I have many friends who scored b/w 290 and 300.

Good luck!

I think you have very very good chances. I am glad I am not a portuguese applicant from your law school. Yale will be the toughest one. You are competing not only with the best from Portugal but also the best from Europe. Did you get a letter from your law school / professor stating that you are the best GPA ever? That might help...

On the Toefl score, my understanding is that the Toefl is not a criterion to rank candidates. They just want to eliminate the applicants who will not understand the classes. That is all. I have many friends who scored b/w 290 and 300.

Good luck!
quote
gar33

Than you guys...

My TOEFL score is not that impressive Roberto. Many people accomplish similar results. I understand the TOEFL to be the most stupid exam in the world and I don't believe it is a good measure of your ability to speak and write fluently in english. I know a chinese guy that got 290 in spite of his terrible english (of course, he is very smart, otherwise it would've been impossible). You should try some exams from the Princeton Review TOEFL CD. But hey: the TOEFL is certainly not the most important issue. If you have a low score, they will just ignore you; if you have a high score, they will just take it as a minimum requirement. It works as a necessary condition, not as part of a sufficient one, to be accepted in Yale...

Hey Vakil, thank you for your kind words! As far as I know, you're at YLS so good luck with your studies and hope to see you in August...

Than you guys...

My TOEFL score is not that impressive Roberto. Many people accomplish similar results. I understand the TOEFL to be the most stupid exam in the world and I don't believe it is a good measure of your ability to speak and write fluently in english. I know a chinese guy that got 290 in spite of his terrible english (of course, he is very smart, otherwise it would've been impossible). You should try some exams from the Princeton Review TOEFL CD. But hey: the TOEFL is certainly not the most important issue. If you have a low score, they will just ignore you; if you have a high score, they will just take it as a minimum requirement. It works as a necessary condition, not as part of a sufficient one, to be accepted in Yale...

Hey Vakil, thank you for your kind words! As far as I know, you're at YLS so good luck with your studies and hope to see you in August...
quote
gar33

Did you get a letter from your law school / professor stating that you are the best GPA ever? That might help...

Yes I think so. I dind't read the letters because I signed the waiver but both my recommenders told me they insisted on that topic. One of them, probably the most reliable from YLS standpoint (he was a visiting professor there once) even wrote down, or so he told me, that I was one of the two or three best students he ever had, including graduate and doctoral students from LSE, Oxford, Harvard, etc. But you never know unless you see it with your own eyes and I didn't...

I was also lucky to meet in Lisbon, after a conference in my school, a guy named John Gardner who is Professor of Jurisprudence at Oxford and was a visiting professor at yale last year. I can't figure why (really...) but after a question during his lecture and five minutes of conversation after it, he told me he would love to write a recommendation letter himself. As he told me: "That will really help you!". He was very kind, although I still can't figure why :-)

Good luck to you too Paul. I hope to see you soon!

Did you get a letter from your law school / professor stating that you are the best GPA ever? That might help...

Yes I think so. I dind't read the letters because I signed the waiver but both my recommenders told me they insisted on that topic. One of them, probably the most reliable from YLS standpoint (he was a visiting professor there once) even wrote down, or so he told me, that I was one of the two or three best students he ever had, including graduate and doctoral students from LSE, Oxford, Harvard, etc. But you never know unless you see it with your own eyes and I didn't...

I was also lucky to meet in Lisbon, after a conference in my school, a guy named John Gardner who is Professor of Jurisprudence at Oxford and was a visiting professor at yale last year. I can't figure why (really...) but after a question during his lecture and five minutes of conversation after it, he told me he would love to write a recommendation letter himself. As he told me: "That will really help you!". He was very kind, although I still can't figure why :-)

Good luck to you too Paul. I hope to see you soon!
quote
Roberto27

I think the toefl score does matter. Many top universities announce the admitted students toefl score average on their websites, and it's frequently 280 or more. Even if you don't give a dime about this exam, you may have to reluctanctly re-sit for it in order to increase your chances of gaining admittance. Other factors do matter as well but i think the results are in no way less telling than other criterias. As to me, i also don't care much about the Toefl, I didn't prepare well for it as i just receive the ETS Prep CD only 2 days before the test date and didn't review it consistently; notwithstanding this i managed to attain very good scores on each sub-section, to my surprise.

I think the toefl score does matter. Many top universities announce the admitted students toefl score average on their websites, and it's frequently 280 or more. Even if you don't give a dime about this exam, you may have to reluctanctly re-sit for it in order to increase your chances of gaining admittance. Other factors do matter as well but i think the results are in no way less telling than other criterias. As to me, i also don't care much about the Toefl, I didn't prepare well for it as i just receive the ETS Prep CD only 2 days before the test date and didn't review it consistently; notwithstanding this i managed to attain very good scores on each sub-section, to my surprise.
quote
Mila

Hi Gar,
I am more or less in the same position as you. Best of my year at a well-known dutch law school, internship at UN, some publications, some research-assistantships and i am the elected student member in the faculty board. However, I am only graduating this year and don't have any work experience.
My career purposes are like yours as well; I want to engage in research and my personal statements were also some sort of research agenda.
Also, I have a recommendation letter from a prof who used to be at harvard. But he also told me that my chances might be small because of my age. I gave it a shot anyway and now I will just have to wait. I applied to 7 law schools and so far I have already been accepted to Upenn and Georgetown. So apparently they didnt care about my age.
The problematic thing however, is that I learned that once you get rejected at a school like harvard your chances to get in some other year are very small.
Well, can do nothing but wait and see.

Hi Gar,
I am more or less in the same position as you. Best of my year at a well-known dutch law school, internship at UN, some publications, some research-assistantships and i am the elected student member in the faculty board. However, I am only graduating this year and don't have any work experience.
My career purposes are like yours as well; I want to engage in research and my personal statements were also some sort of research agenda.
Also, I have a recommendation letter from a prof who used to be at harvard. But he also told me that my chances might be small because of my age. I gave it a shot anyway and now I will just have to wait. I applied to 7 law schools and so far I have already been accepted to Upenn and Georgetown. So apparently they didnt care about my age.
The problematic thing however, is that I learned that once you get rejected at a school like harvard your chances to get in some other year are very small.
Well, can do nothing but wait and see.
quote
yueping

I don't understand the purpose of this post : if you're the "best student ever of a top law school" in your country and have an outstanding record, then your chances are very good. What is there to discuss about and what else is there to say ?

I don't understand the purpose of this post : if you're the "best student ever of a top law school" in your country and have an outstanding record, then your chances are very good. What is there to discuss about and what else is there to say ?
quote
gar33

Hi Gar,
I am more or less in the same position as you. Best of my year at a well-known dutch law school, internship at UN, some publications, some research-assistantships and i am the elected student member in the faculty board. However, I am only graduating this year and don't have any work experience. .


I'm also graduating this year, so we're basically in the same situation. And I don't have any work experience either... Vakil says that age doen't matter and another LLM student at Yale sent me a privete message stressing the same point, so "RELAX"! (I'm a bit more relaxed now)

I hope we are not competing for the last place :-)

The funny thing is that after all there is plenty of room for luck in the whole process... I think you're credentials are awesome. Hope we can meet in New Haven or Cambridge! Good Luck!

<blockquote>Hi Gar,
I am more or less in the same position as you. Best of my year at a well-known dutch law school, internship at UN, some publications, some research-assistantships and i am the elected student member in the faculty board. However, I am only graduating this year and don't have any work experience. .</blockquote>

I'm also graduating this year, so we're basically in the same situation. And I don't have any work experience either... Vakil says that age doen't matter and another LLM student at Yale sent me a privete message stressing the same point, so "RELAX"! (I'm a bit more relaxed now)

I hope we are not competing for the last place :-)

The funny thing is that after all there is plenty of room for luck in the whole process... I think you're credentials are awesome. Hope we can meet in New Haven or Cambridge! Good Luck!
quote
gar33

I don't understand the purpose of this post : if you're the "best student ever of a top law school" in your country and have an outstanding record, then your chances are very good. What is there to discuss about and what else is there to say ?


Hi!

Thank you for your kind words. I shall explain myself: when someone is attempting to be accepted to the best Law School in the US, being "the best" in his own country is not enough. I'm not questioning my credentials. What I wanted to know is what other people both already at Yale or applying this year have to say about my credentials. They could have said they are formidable, but just not good enough...

The purpose of this post is serious and, contrary to your suggestion, fully accomplished by now: I'm better informed about my chances and I gave other "best" students the opportunity to measure their own chances more accurately.

Now, you may be questioning the "purpose" at a more fundamental level: why would someone waste his time posting on his chances? After several months of a stressing application process the answer should be obvious to anyone. Those who are not here with the purpose of asking concrete questions about the application process, probably want to share their concerns with some of their peers. That is my case. I hope it doesn't bother you.

Regards and Good Luck!

<blockquote>I don't understand the purpose of this post : if you're the "best student ever of a top law school" in your country and have an outstanding record, then your chances are very good. What is there to discuss about and what else is there to say ?</blockquote>

Hi!

Thank you for your kind words. I shall explain myself: when someone is attempting to be accepted to the best Law School in the US, being "the best" in his own country is not enough. I'm not questioning my credentials. What I wanted to know is what other people both already at Yale or applying this year have to say about my credentials. They could have said they are formidable, but just not good enough...

The purpose of this post is serious and, contrary to your suggestion, fully accomplished by now: I'm better informed about my chances and I gave other "best" students the opportunity to measure their own chances more accurately.

Now, you may be questioning the "purpose" at a more fundamental level: why would someone waste his time posting on his chances? After several months of a stressing application process the answer should be obvious to anyone. Those who are not here with the purpose of asking concrete questions about the application process, probably want to share their concerns with some of their peers. That is my case. I hope it doesn't bother you.

Regards and Good Luck!
quote
gar33

I think the toefl score does matter. Many top universities announce the admitted students toefl score average on their websites, and it's frequently 280 or more. Even if you don't give a dime about this exam, you may have to reluctanctly re-sit for it in order to increase your chances of gaining admittance. Other factors do matter as well but i think the results are in no way less telling than other criterias. As to me, i also don't care much about the Toefl, I didn't prepare well for it as i just receive the ETS Prep CD only 2 days before the test date and didn't review it consistently; notwithstanding this i managed to attain very good scores on each sub-section, to my surprise.


Maybe you're right Roberto27...
You're quite right when you say that it does matter; I was just challenging the importance you seem to ascribe to the TEOFL score, but perhaps it is far more important than I believe it is. We all know that there are no rules concerning the relative importance of the application materials, so we can't do much more than pure speculation.

Congratulations and Good Luck!

<blockquote>I think the toefl score does matter. Many top universities announce the admitted students toefl score average on their websites, and it's frequently 280 or more. Even if you don't give a dime about this exam, you may have to reluctanctly re-sit for it in order to increase your chances of gaining admittance. Other factors do matter as well but i think the results are in no way less telling than other criterias. As to me, i also don't care much about the Toefl, I didn't prepare well for it as i just receive the ETS Prep CD only 2 days before the test date and didn't review it consistently; notwithstanding this i managed to attain very good scores on each sub-section, to my surprise.</blockquote>

Maybe you're right Roberto27...
You're quite right when you say that it does matter; I was just challenging the importance you seem to ascribe to the TEOFL score, but perhaps it is far more important than I believe it is. We all know that there are no rules concerning the relative importance of the application materials, so we can't do much more than pure speculation.

Congratulations and Good Luck!
quote
Paul

I respect your views but I have friends who went to Harvard, Stanford and Yale and I had the chance to meet professors from the admissions committee of some top schools. They were unanimous: after a certain score, TOEFL is not important. When you are short-listed to these schools, you are competing with teh very best. Great credentials, grades, rec. letters, personal statements, etc. Do you really think that b/c one candidate has a TOEFL of 290 and the other one has 280/270, this will be a factor? Please...

I got 293 btw.

I respect your views but I have friends who went to Harvard, Stanford and Yale and I had the chance to meet professors from the admissions committee of some top schools. They were unanimous: after a certain score, TOEFL is not important. When you are short-listed to these schools, you are competing with teh very best. Great credentials, grades, rec. letters, personal statements, etc. Do you really think that b/c one candidate has a TOEFL of 290 and the other one has 280/270, this will be a factor? Please...

I got 293 btw.
quote
Roberto27

I think the results have some bearing though limited. Consider this scenario: Two applicants with similar credentials, both of them hold weighty personal statements, impressive work experience, extremely relevant community service and excellent grades; nonetheless, we meet a slight difference, namely, one got 270 on the Toefl while the other outdid him with a toefl of 290. Now, let's imagine that the Admissions Committee doesn't have more than one space to spare, Could you please forecast which one will probably be granted admission?

I think the results have some bearing though limited. Consider this scenario: Two applicants with similar credentials, both of them hold weighty personal statements, impressive work experience, extremely relevant community service and excellent grades; nonetheless, we meet a slight difference, namely, one got 270 on the Toefl while the other outdid him with a toefl of 290. Now, let's imagine that the Admissions Committee doesn't have more than one space to spare, Could you please forecast which one will probably be granted admission?
quote
gar33

I respect your views but I have friends who went to Harvard, Stanford and Yale and I had the chance to meet professors from the admissions committee of some top schools. They were unanimous: after a certain score, TOEFL is not important. When you are short-listed to these schools, you are competing with teh very best. Great credentials, grades, rec. letters, personal statements, etc. Do you really think that b/c one candidate has a TOEFL of 290 and the other one has 280/270, this will be a factor? Please...


That is also my opinion. In fact, a smart person would easily catch up with those scoring 10/15 more points in the TOEFL after some weeks of intense readings and class participation. Moreover, high TOEFL scores don't account for your ability to speak or write english in a higlhy demanding environment. I got 6.0 on essay rating but I often make mistakes when I am deeply concentrated in my writing, let alone when I am typing posts :-). The same can be said about speaking or even reading. Most of us hope to learn fast and that's all.
If a guy's TOEFL score is bellow 260 or so, then the result should have a negative impact.

However, as I said in my response to Roberto, I'm just speculating. But Paul's insight seems to be quite conclusive, at least in my view.

<blockquote>I respect your views but I have friends who went to Harvard, Stanford and Yale and I had the chance to meet professors from the admissions committee of some top schools. They were unanimous: after a certain score, TOEFL is not important. When you are short-listed to these schools, you are competing with teh very best. Great credentials, grades, rec. letters, personal statements, etc. Do you really think that b/c one candidate has a TOEFL of 290 and the other one has 280/270, this will be a factor? Please...</blockquote>

That is also my opinion. In fact, a smart person would easily catch up with those scoring 10/15 more points in the TOEFL after some weeks of intense readings and class participation. Moreover, high TOEFL scores don't account for your ability to speak or write english in a higlhy demanding environment. I got 6.0 on essay rating but I often make mistakes when I am deeply concentrated in my writing, let alone when I am typing posts :-). The same can be said about speaking or even reading. Most of us hope to learn fast and that's all.
If a guy's TOEFL score is bellow 260 or so, then the result should have a negative impact.

However, as I said in my response to Roberto, I'm just speculating. But Paul's insight seems to be quite conclusive, at least in my view.
quote
Roberto27

I don't regard Paul's argument as seamless . It is very persuasive, though.

I don't regard Paul's argument as seamless . It is very persuasive, though.
quote
ermoncel

Isn't there any chance if your GPA is 3.04 or something like it?

Isn't there any chance if your GPA is 3.04 or something like it?
quote

Reply to Post

Related Law Schools

New Haven, Connecticut 377 Followers 383 Discussions

Other Related Content

U.S. News Releases Long-Delayed Law School Rankings, With Some Major Shifts

News May 15, 2023

Hot Discussions