I am a 2007 grad from a lower tier 1 (top 60) school. I graduated top 50% but I wrote on to law review. I also have 15 years experience in management consulting (mostly with a big-5 level firm). I got an A in Basic Fed Tax and a B in Business Tax. Do I have any shot at one of the big 3 (NYU, GULC, UF)? I also went to UF undergrad.

Thanks

Just apply. Doesn't hurt...
Besides, if you apply via LSAC you are allowed to send five reports. Choose those three and two other "easier" schools...