I was just wondering if any of you have completed, or are currently on, any of the LLM courses at Birkbeck. What are your opinions on the courses, teaching and resources etc.
I know lots of you may have opinions about Birkbeck in comparison with other Uni's etc., but I am interested in further academic study and a more critical approach to the law and human rights...so opinions from those with direct experience of any of the Borkbeck courses would be great.
Many thanks.
Birkbeck LLM
Posted Jan 06, 2012 12:16
I know lots of you may have opinions about Birkbeck in comparison with other Uni's etc., but I am interested in further academic study and a more critical approach to the law and human rights...so opinions from those with direct experience of any of the Borkbeck courses would be great.
Many thanks.
Posted Jan 21, 2012 03:55
I am considering applying there as well. Do you know if they require letters of recommendation for the application?
I have heard that they are a kind of 'political correctness' academy with a strong identity politics agenda. Do you know if this is true?
I have heard that they are a kind of 'political correctness' academy with a strong identity politics agenda. Do you know if this is true?
Posted Jan 21, 2012 17:17
I finished the accelerated LLB (now LLM QLD) at Birkbeck last year.
I don't know if 'political correctness' is the right phrase, but the gist of this criticism (if it is a criticism) is spot on. Birkbeck thinks of itself as a 'sociolegal' law school and most of the academics there align themselves closely with so-called 'critical legal studies' and related movements. Most of the teaching is motivated by a rather crass political agenda, and is of a poor standard. The thinking of most of the lecturers is lacking in analytical rigour, and some of the lectures are simply embarrassing. There are also a handful of lecturers and seminar leaders (postgraduate students) whose teaching is all but incomprehensible because their English is so bad.
I have seen Birkbeck adverts with the line "Great minds don't think alike". This is very much not the motto of the law school. As a graduate student you would be out of place there if you don't feel at home with a very specific (in my opinion intellectually bankrupt) way of thinking - postmodernism, critical legal studies etc. Basically any discipline that insecurely prefaces itself with 'critical' in order to assure itself of its trailblazing anti-establishment credentials will fit the bill nicely.
I don't know if 'political correctness' is the right phrase, but the gist of this criticism (if it is a criticism) is spot on. Birkbeck thinks of itself as a 'sociolegal' law school and most of the academics there align themselves closely with so-called 'critical legal studies' and related movements. Most of the teaching is motivated by a rather crass political agenda, and is of a poor standard. The thinking of most of the lecturers is lacking in analytical rigour, and some of the lectures are simply embarrassing. There are also a handful of lecturers and seminar leaders (postgraduate students) whose teaching is all but incomprehensible because their English is so bad.
I have seen Birkbeck adverts with the line "Great minds don't think alike". This is very much not the motto of the law school. As a graduate student you would be out of place there if you don't feel at home with a very specific (in my opinion intellectually bankrupt) way of thinking - postmodernism, critical legal studies etc. Basically any discipline that insecurely prefaces itself with 'critical' in order to assure itself of its trailblazing anti-establishment credentials will fit the bill nicely.
Posted Jan 21, 2012 21:19
I am considering applying there as well. Do you know if they require letters of recommendation for the application?
I have heard that they are a kind of 'political correctness' academy with a strong identity politics agenda. Do you know if this is true?
You don't need a letter of recommendation, but you do need two references and a statement of purpose.
Not sure what exactly you mean by 'political correctness academy', but if you have a look at the course content for each LLM on their website (it also lists some of reading material) you'll get an idea of the angle the courses come at the law from.
I have heard that they are a kind of 'political correctness' academy with a strong identity politics agenda. Do you know if this is true?</blockquote>
You don't need a letter of recommendation, but you do need two references and a statement of purpose.
Not sure what exactly you mean by 'political correctness academy', but if you have a look at the course content for each LLM on their website (it also lists some of reading material) you'll get an idea of the angle the courses come at the law from.
Posted Jan 21, 2012 21:55
Thanks for the replies. The usual theory is that the 'Critical Legal Studies' approach to law had more or less run itself into the ground by the end of the 1990s, so I guess Birkbeck is living in a time-warp. If you doubt every intellectual construct as a disguise for some illegitimate substantive interest, then eventually you dissolve your capacity to claim that your own substantive interest is superior, since you've destroyed all standards of validity.
Posted Jan 21, 2012 22:34
Thanks for the replies. The usual theory is that the 'Critical Legal Studies' approach to law had more or less run itself into the ground by the end of the 1990s, so I guess Birkbeck is living in a time-warp. If you doubt every intellectual construct as a disguise for some illegitimate substantive interest, then eventually you dissolve your capacity to claim that your own substantive interest is superior, since you've destroyed all standards of validity.
Quite.
If you think that, and you can put it as eloquently as that, Birkbeck is not the place for you!
Quite.
If you think that, and you can put it as eloquently as that, Birkbeck is not the place for you!
Related Law Schools
Hot Discussions
-
Cambridge LL.M. Applicants 2024-2025
Oct 30, 2024 142,434 544 -
Stanford 2024-2025
Nov 07, 2024 35,107 117 -
MIDS - 2024-25
Nov 15, 2024 1,843 16 -
Harvard LLM 2025-2026
Nov 20 09:34 PM 1,762 7 -
Scholarship Negotiation Strategy (BCL v. NYU LLM Dean's Graduate Scholarship)
Nov 09, 2024 1,044 4 -
EU citizen barred in the US -- will an LLM from an EU school help me practice law somewhere in the EU?
Nov 15, 2024 141 4 -
LLM in Germany 2024
Nov 09, 2024 830 4 -
Osgoode LLM - Fall 2025
Nov 21 08:35 AM 108 3